Skip to content
Welcome / Blog Archive / English / 2026-11-doc2 EU Directive 2026/799 demands “coordinated” harmonisation of national insolvency laws

2026-11-doc2 EU Directive 2026/799 demands “coordinated” harmonisation of national insolvency laws

For fifteen years, Europe’s legal and financial world in the field of insolvency and restructuring has been full of it: harmonisation! Harmonisation of national insolvency laws of all its member states? Is this in any way feasible? Or is it “all hell breaks loose”? It may be hard to imagine but around fifteen years ago, the topic of “harmonisation of national insolvency laws” was a no-go area in practice and academia. The “H-word” was forbidden.

That same word has now – a decade and a half later – resulted in two fully-fledged directives (the Preventive Restructuring Directive 2019/1023 and the Directive on harmonisation of certain aspects of insolvency law, CAD 2026/799) containing a total of over 90 legislative provisions and no fewer than 180 recitals preceding those texts. Even more remarkable—or, if you will, more incomprehensible—is that in both legislative documents the term “harmonisation” appears only four times: three times in the CAD 2026/799 and just once in the PRD 2019/1023. Two superior EU-level legislative instruments and they do not contain a single indication of what “harmonisation” means!

Notwithstanding continuing discussions between practitioners and academic scholars, during the second decade of this century the EU began bringing national insolvency laws closer together, a process variously described in treaties as “harmonisation”, “approximation” or “convergence”.

Harmonisation can be regarded as a process of deliberate legislative activity in which diverse elements of legal systems are combined or adapted to each other to create a coherent body of rules or principles. Harmonisation implies purpose and focussed action, what can be called in Latin terms: “animus harmonisandi”, the real and sincere will to harmonise. In the words of Emilie Ghio of the University of Edinburgh, legal harmonisation in the EU is a conscious and inclusive process, with the involvement of respective actors in the insolvency field: policymakers and legislative branches, practitioners, judges and scholars. Insolvency law is not developed behind closed doors by the European institutions, cosily working together on a square mile in Brussels. Rather, it takes place in an open debate with stakeholders, including the European Commission’s Expert Group on Restructuring and Insolvency Law. All these stakeholders to a certain extent are co-drivers of the harmonisation process.This model of mutual influence and pragmatic evolution is seen as offering a viable path forward for European insolvency law; one that reinforces market integration while respecting domestic autonomy.

Can we assign a specific term or characterisation to this form of harmonisation? Is it possible to indicate—by way of a single designation—which method is being followed within the EU regarding the convergence of national insolvency and restructuring laws?

The text of the CAD 2026/799 offers around 30 legislative options for member states, the degree of which indicates the discretion or freedom given to these states. As a side mark: the options included in the PRD 2019/1023 added up to some 70 such options, leading German professor Reinhard Bork and Italian professor Renato Mangano to argue these options could lead to ‘… actually disharmonising’ restructuring law. The system allowing member states to work with various options is, indeed, not without complexities. Take, for example, the rules requiring directors to file for the opening of insolvency proceedings within three months of becoming aware, or being reasonably expected to have become aware, of the company’s insolvency. Several member states may already have broadly equivalent or closely comparable rules in place. In other member states, these rules are “new” or (only partly) flow from national norms concerning rather abstract rules of wrongful trading and the like: Cyprus, Denmark, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Malta, the Netherlands and Sweden.

How can the system under Title V of CAD 2026/799 be harmonised with the rules on directors’ duties to request the opening of insolvency proceedings and civil liability? Title V contains only three articles, yet together they give member states at a minimum of four locations, there is a choice between two options, and at two locations, there is a choice between three options. As a result, on this issue alone, the 27 member states, including Denmark, could ultimately end up with around 100 different sets of detailed rules across the EU internal market.

In recent conferences a specific characterisation for the type of harmonisation has been suggested. These conferences are taking place across Europe to explain and discuss the newly introduced system for harmonising avoidance actions, pre-packs, the director’s duty to file for insolvency, etc. At a conference in Paris, the discussion touched upon the latitude the text grants to individual member states. Professor Pinto-Ferreira of the Nova School of Law in Portugal framed this in the context of the “latest intervention” from Brussels into national insolvency laws. The CAD 2026/799 leaves significant discretion, resulting in what he terms as “EU-managed diversity” as the chosen approach for transposing the directive’s provisions. At a conference in Rome, Associate professor Eugenio Vaccari of Royal Holloway, University of London described this system as “governed pluralism”. If there is a clear underlying rationale, one could argue—from an EU perspective—that this represents the implementation of “orchestrated diversity” based on common rules. This suggests that the diversity in the specific (detailed) national rules adopted is not merely incidental, but the result of deliberately coordinated action.

Perhaps “coordinated diversity” or “harmonised diversity” is the more appropriate term. In Vilnius, Dr Signe Viimsalu, the director of the Insolvency Service of Estonia, made a compelling argument that member states should not approach the transposition of these texts in isolation; rather, they should coordinate their efforts with one another. This seems particularly relevant for countries with specialised government services or agencies vested with statutory insolvency powers controlling insolvency practitioners and insolvency proceedings—such as Cyprus, Estonia, Lithuania, and Romania. These powers are quite broad and encompass tasks such as developing and interconnecting ICT systems, including insolvency registers, databases, and standardised information fact sheets. Coordination indeed seems an obvious way to follow.

When focusing specifically on the system for harmonising substantive legal rules, a term like “coordinated harmonisation” seems fitting. The basis of CAD 2026/799 is that the time required to complete insolvency proceedings and the large divergences in recovery value have negative repercussions on cost predictability for creditors and investors in cross-border situations in the internal market. And it is this divergence among the rules of member states that reduces the attractiveness of cross-border investments. Present divergence creates barriers and impacts the cross-border movement of capital within the EU and to and from third countries. For this reason, the EU wishes the harmonisation of certain aspects of insolvency law that could require changes to be made to the laws of some member states. In particular, the European Commission submits, the large differences between national restructuring and insolvency regimes in the EU are unnecessarily restricting cross-border investment. Convergence of restructuring and insolvency regimes would make it easier for investors to assess credit risk and therefore facilitate greater legal certainty for cross-border investments.

My experience at such conferences is that new proposals are compared against existing rules within the national legal systems. Legal experts are very skilled and inventive in this regard, analysing how EU regulations align with national rules down to the finest detail. Yet, in doing so, isn’t the central objective of CAD 2026/799 being lost from sight? Ultimately, the goal is to make the EU’s internal market more attractive to investors. Shouldn’t this overarching purpose lead to national legislators aligning and coordinating their efforts as much as possible? The aim is not so much to create a coherent body of rules as to coordinate legislative action towards that goal. For me, the characterisation should be: coordinated harmonisation.

References

Bob Wessels, The H-word is out, in: European Company Law (ECL) 2011, p. 27 et seq.

Emilie Ghio, Rethinking Harmonisation. Lessons from Insolvency Law, Edward Elgar Publishing, 2022.

Emilie Ghio and Grigoris Bacharis, Insolvency and EU Law (July 25, 2025). Edinburgh School of Law Research Paper No. 2025/23, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=5401877 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.54. 01877.

Reinhard Bork and Renato Mangano, European Cross-Border Insolvency Law, Oxford University Press, 2nd ed. 2022, p. 1.100.

 

 

This is a slightly adapted version of a regular column Bob Wessels is writing for Global Restructuring Review (GRR) on the topic of cross-border restructuring and insolvency in a European context. GRR is a subscription-only publication and the column appeared in GRR on November 3, 2026. See www.globalrestructuringreview.com.